Australian Dollars (AUD)
British Pound (GBP)
Canadian Dollar (CAD)
Euro (EUR)
Written by: Monique from The Anal Sex Toys Shop
Publish on 18/05/2026
Choosing your first anal toy can feel more confusing than it should.
It’s easy to look at a page full of plugs, dildos, sets, and vibrating toys and wonder which one is actually going to feel good — not just look exciting online.
For most beginners, the best choice is not the biggest toy or the most intense-looking one. It’s usually something smaller, smoother, and easier to relax with.
This guide focuses on helping you choose beginner-friendly toys — including small butt plugs, slim anal dildos, and beginner sets that make the first few experiences feel less intimidating.
If you're completely new to anal play, our Beginner’s Guide to Anal Play covers the basics before choosing toys.
What Makes an Anal Toy Beginner-Friendly
A beginner-friendly toy should make you feel like you can take your time, not like you need to force yourself to keep up with it.
That usually means looking for toys with:
- Smaller, more manageable sizes
- Smooth shapes that feel easier to insert
- Softer materials that feel gentler on the body
- Flared bases for safer anal play
- Shapes that don’t feel intimidating the moment you see them
A lot of first-time discomfort comes from choosing something that looks exciting online but feels difficult to actually relax with.
Once you switch to something smaller and smoother, the experience can feel completely different.
Small Butt Plugs for Beginners
Small butt plugs are often the easiest place to start because they feel simple, steady, and less overwhelming than longer toys.
Instead of focusing on movement or depth, a small plug gives you a chance to get used to the feeling of fullness at your own pace.
Beginner-friendly plugs usually work best when they have:
- A slim tip
- A smooth tapered shape
- Softer silicone
- A comfortable flared base
Many people who struggle with larger toys at first end up enjoying anal play far more once they switch to something smaller and smoother.
If you’re looking for approachable beginner-friendly options, our Small Anal Toys collection focuses on slimmer shapes and easier-to-use designs.
Still unsure what size feels best to start with? Our What Size Butt Plug Should I Start With guide explains why smaller sizes usually feel much easier for beginners.
Slim Anal Dildos for Beginners
Slim anal dildos can be a good choice if you want something with a little more movement than a plug, but still want to keep things beginner-friendly.
The goal is not to choose the most dramatic shape. It is to choose something your body can actually relax around.
For beginners, slim dildos usually feel easier when they have:
- Gentle curves
- Softer silicone
- Smoother surfaces
- Manageable thickness
A smoother slim dildo often feels far better than trying to force yourself into something that looks more intense but feels difficult to relax with.
If you’re still figuring out what feels comfortable, our Beginner Anal Toys collection focuses on first-time-friendly shapes and softer materials designed to feel easier to use.
If plugs feel like the direction you want to start with, our Beginner Butt Plug Guide walks through shape, material, and size in more detail.
Are Beginner Anal Sets Worth It?
Beginner anal sets can make the whole process feel a lot less stressful.
Instead of trying to guess the perfect size immediately, a beginner set lets you start with something smaller and work out what actually feels comfortable for your body.
That usually feels much easier than buying one toy and hoping you made the right choice.
Most beginner sets focus on:
- Slim beginner-friendly sizes
- Smooth tapered shapes
- Gradual size progression
- Softer silicone materials
A lot of people end up enjoying beginner sets simply because they remove the pressure of needing to “get it right” the first time.
If you like the idea of starting smaller and progressing naturally, our Beginner Anal Sets collection includes softer starter-friendly sets designed for comfortable early exploration.
Once you’ve chosen something beginner-friendly, our How to Use a Butt Plug guide can help you ease into the first few uses more comfortably.
Should Beginners Choose Vibration?
Vibration can be a good option if you want more sensation without jumping straight into a larger toy.
Some beginners prefer to keep things simple at first. Others find that gentle vibration makes a smaller toy feel more exciting without adding much extra pressure.
Vibrating toys can be useful if you want:
- More sensation from a slimmer shape
- Stimulation without extreme fullness
- A softer way to explore intensity
- Something that feels different from size alone
A slimmer vibrating toy can sometimes feel far more satisfying than a much larger non-vibrating one.
If vibration sounds more appealing than size, our Vibrating Anal Toys collection includes gentler beginner-friendly options designed for comfortable stimulation.
How to Choose the Best Anal Toy for Beginners
If you’re unsure where to start, try not to think of this as choosing the “best” toy in general.
Think of it as choosing the toy that feels right for where you are now.
A good beginner choice usually feels:
- Unintimidating
- Matched to your current comfort level
- Smooth rather than overly textured
- Soft enough to feel forgiving
- Easy to relax with mentally as well as physically
A toy that feels comfortable enough to actually enjoy is usually a much better starting point than something chosen purely for intensity.
Using enough lubricant and taking things slowly also tends to make a much bigger difference than most people expect.
If you’re still learning what feels comfortable, our Anal Lube Guide can help you choose the right lubricant, while our First Time Anal Tips guide walks through how to make the first experience feel smoother and more relaxed.
FAQ
What feels easiest for beginners to start with?
A small plug or slim silicone toy usually feels easiest because it gives your body time to relax.
The first toy should feel manageable, not like something you need to “push through.”
Will a small anal toy still feel good?
Yes. Smaller toys can feel surprisingly satisfying when the shape is smooth and you’re relaxed enough to enjoy it.
For beginners, comfort often creates more pleasure than size.
Do plugs and dildos feel different?
Yes. Plugs usually feel more steady and filling, while slim dildos give more movement and shape. If you want something simple, start with a plug.
If you want more motion, a slim dildo may feel better.
Are beginner anal sets less intimidating?
Usually, yes. A beginner set removes the pressure of choosing one perfect size.
You can start with the smallest option and move up only when it feels right.
What makes a beginner toy feel comfortable?
A comfortable beginner toy usually has a smoother shape, softer material, manageable size, and a base that feels secure.
The goal is to help your body relax, not overwhelm it.
'%3E%3CanimateTransform attributeName='transform' type='rotate' from='0 50 50' to='360 50 50' repeatCount='indefinite' dur='1s'%3E%3C/animateTransform%3E%3C/path%3E%3C/svg%3E)